CHARR.COM
Join | Follow us   

Reveiw: Dredd 3D

Dredd 3D is much more faithful adaptation of the Judge Dredd comics, is it still guilty of being a crime against the comic its based on?




Jpinlac, Published on Oct 07, 2012
British pop culture has always been on my radar but I never developed a, um, bond with Judge Dredd. The 1995 movie was silly but I enjoyed it for its cheesy value. The new movie Dredd 3D is a bit more on the visceral side, but it doesn't completely overwhelm me and make me a new fan of the Judge Dredd character that I would want to be.

Unfortunately, the story was similar to the recent Asian blockbuster The Raid: Redemption. I am not saying they stole the idea for the plot, but because The Raid came out first and featured some excellent martial arts choreography, it overshadowed an interesting story in Dredd 3D. It made it something that you unfortunately may have seen before. There is one difference, that of the 3D and it added a bit of Hollywood flair to the familiar storyline.

Slow motion and special effects were given a reason to be in the film and even added to the impact of certain scenes. No big spoilers here, but Dredd tackles a drug gang with a recruit-in-training. The drug supposedly slows down sensory experience and thus added some cool scenes for 3D and shock value violence. It was nice to see a comic book movie stick to a basic story without other stories intersecting, but I was hoping to learn more about the dystopian society that is Mega City. There were a few glimpses into the future of East Coast America that left you wanting to know more.

Some of the Mega City One's other judges.


Judge Dredd, despite being a British creation, takes place in America. It sets it up for a better story if they make another movie. The bottom line for this movie is the level of violence that made me want to see it to begin with. Did enough destruction of property get damaged, enough blood shed and enough women and children put in harm's way? There's a good deal of violence but I feel nothing really new and original and not as much that would make feel ashamed I saw this movie.

Yikes! Is this what I really need to see before I recommend a movie? Maybe I have seen too many, even when violence in real life was what made me choose not to watch Dark Knight Rises when it premiered. I guess enough time has passed and I am okay with watching death onscreen again. I can't believe I am even writing these words. To sum up, I recommend seeing it only if you didn't see Raid:The Redemption or a Judge Dredd fan. Otherwise, it will keep until available on DVD or cable.

TAGS: Comics , Movies , Reviews , Opinions



4 Comments Gravatar used for avatar images - Get your Gravatar here.

Comments can be editted as long as you are logged in or have checked the 'Remember me' box before posting a comment. An 'Edit' link will be added on all of the comments you created with those credentials.


Newest first Oldest first

  1. isorod

    Yeah if you could provide an over and a link to the flicker feed would be great.

    I'm pretty late on this reply too.

    #4 – 28 November, 2012 at 8:19 am

  2. Josef

    Sorry for the late reply. Pics are up in my flickr. I can write a short overview for you too if you like.

    #3 – 16 November, 2012 at 9:07 am

  3. IsoRod

    Yeah, I tried to get a lot of legal references in that one. That's sad, I thought the Dredd Heads would be out in full force. So how was the comic-con? Do you have pics up on your site? I can create a post to link to your stuff.

    #2 – 16 October, 2012 at 12:39 pm

  4. Josef

    Great subtitle! The movie had funny moments but some online forums had die-hard Dredd fans wanting more humor. You know a movie didn't quite have an impact when you don't see people at the 2012 New York Comic Con dressed up as any of the characters.

    #1 – 16 October, 2012 at 8:48 am

Post a comment (Optional)
  • Allowed markup: <a> <i> <b> <em> <u> <s> <strong> <code> <pre> <p>
  • All other tags will be stripped, unless they are in a <pre>
  • (use this for blocks of code). External links will have the
  • External links will have the rel="nofollow" attribute applied